HDMI

High-Definition Multimedia Interface is a compact audio/video interface for transmitting uncompressed digital data.

Often multimedia PC's comes with a HDMI output.
Not everybody is enthusiastic about the sound quality.

Of the many problems associated with HDMI, the audio quality is totally handicapped for lack of -- a pin! They designed the connector before they finished designing the system. They didn't have enough pins to also have a master audio clock.

So with HDMI, the audio clock is derived from the video clock. For high-def TV, the video clock runs at either 74.25 MHz or 74.25 * (1000/1001) [thank you NTSC!!!]. The audio clock runs at multiples of 48 kHz. Of course, these are not related. So the receiver has a PLL to regenerate an audio clock based on instructions from the transmitter (source) telling it what to do.

The result is the worst jitter of any system yet invented. It truly sucks.

Much later, they added a thing called Audio Rate Control in HDMI 1.3a. This puts a buffer and the master audio clock in the receiver. Then commands are sent upstream on the CEC line telling the player to speed up and slow down as necessary to keep the buffer full.
Charles Hansen

In the Feb 2009 edition of the Hi-fi News magazine Paul Miller measured the following jitter results for a few A/V amplifiers:

Denon AVR-3803A
---------------
SPDIF: 560psec
HDMI: 3700psec

Onkyo TX-NR906
---------------
SPDIF: 470psec
HDMI: 3860psec

Pioneer SC-LX81
---------------
SPDIF: 37psec
HDMI: 50psec

Yamaha RX-V3900
---------------
SPDIF: 183psec
HDMI: 7660psec

Amirm

 

Jitter level comparison (lower is better):

Jitter with SPDIF input:
10ps Classe SSP800
15ps DCS Scarlatti
37ps Pioneer SC-LX81
40ps Cambridge DACMagic
50ps Arcam AVR600
121ps Sony SCD-XA5400ES
183ps Yamaha RX-V3900
250ps Denon 2500/AVP-A1
430ps Onkyo PR-SC886
470ps Onkyo TX-NR906
485ps Audiolab 8000AP
560ps Denon 3808A

Jitter with HDMI input:
5ps Arcam AVR600
21ps Classe SSP800
50ps Pioneer SC-LX81
200ps Sony XA5400ES HATS on
2200ps Denon 2500/AVP-A1
3700ps Denon 3808A
3860ps Onkyo TX-NR906
3920ps Onkyo PR-SC886
7660ps Yamaha RX-V3900
8000ps Sony XA5400ES HATS off
8490ps Audiolab 8000AP

Source: AVS Forum.

In a 2016 article, Amir Majidimehr returned to the subject.
The situation seemed to have improved, probably because DACs using asynchronous sample rate conversion coped much better with the jiter inherent in HDMI.

A Deep Dive into HDMI Audio Performance - Amir Majidimehr 2016

 

He also tested a Monoprice Blackbird 4K series HDMI 7.1 audio extractor ($30)

The analog out was poor but the SPDIF output was excellent. Feed the SPDIF into a good quality DAC and you get good performance from HDMI.

Monoprice Blackbird Review (HDMI Audio Extractor) - Amir Majidimehr 2022

References

 

 

Essence HDACC $699

DAC with HDMI input

THis allows you to listen to the LPCM 24 bit/192K 2 Channel soundtracks on Blu-ray.

Added 3/2015

CYP AU-D250 £390.00

DAC with HDMI Bypass and Audio Breakout

Added 3/2015